Morgan Herrick, a 3-sport athlete, spent the majority of her playing time on the basketball court, achieving First-Team All-Conference status all four years at CHS and All-State honors her junior and senior years. Additionally, Morgan was named North Shore Conference Player of the Year for three years and was a member of the Wisconsin All-Star Team her senior year. Named the CHS Basketball team's most valuable player for 4 years and team captain for 3 years, Morgan helped her team reach the semi-finals of the Wisconsin Division 1 State Basketball Tournament her junior year. In her career at CHS, Morgan is currently the all-time leading scorer, 2nd in all-time rebounds, and 3rd all-time assists and steals.

In Volleyball, Morgan was a 4-year letter winner and team captain her senior year, leading her team to three North Shore Conference Championships. She achieved All-Conference status her junior and senior years and All-State Honorable Mention her junior year.

As a varsity softball player for 2 years, Morgan earned 2 letters and All=Conference Honors her freshman and sophomore year.

Morgan continued playing basketball at Drake University and at the University of Chicago, where, in her senior year, she was UAA Conference Player of the Year, All-Central Region First Team honoree, Player of the Year Central Region, and All-American First Team.