Michelle Hannam Schueller was a three-sport standout athlete at Cedarburg High School, earning 10 letters from 1998 to 2001 in volleyball, basketball, and softball. She was also elected team captain her senior year in volleyball and basketball. In volleyball, Michelle was twice named All-Conference Player and Player of the Year and held several team records. She was also named All-Conference Player in basketball twice and All-Conference Player in softball four times, earning the distinction of being selected to the All-State Team.

After graduation, Michelle attended the University Wisconsin, LaCrosse and competed in softball. After transferring to Concordia University, she also competed in volleyball for three years. 

Michelle has still been active in all three sports, coaching softball, basketball and volleyball at local high schools.